I've always ordered from Regan nursery(barefoot only), they are all doing well, unless I moved them to a bad spot, like a shady spot and the rose died. Or I picked the wrong rose like a landscaping one, so I'm going to get rid of it.
I ordered a few roses that were on sale from J&P this year, even though I did hear bad thing from them, they all did well in my yard, that's why I ordered with them again. Will see. Same with Rose Unlimited. But their plants are 1 gallon, small but surviving well in my yard. But I'm a rose newbie. I'm not sure I will order anything from Palatine this year, but I will order from Regan nursery again.